ISO 42001 vs. ISO 27001: a comparative overview

In the world of business, standards are the bedrock of trust and quality. International Organization for Standardization (ISO) standards provide frameworks that help organisations manage processes, reduce risks, and ensure consistency. Certification is a signal to customers, stakeholders, and regulators that a business is committed to excellence.

This article will explore two critical standards: the well-established ISO 27001 for Information Security Management Systems, and the new ISO 42001 for Artificial Intelligence Management Systems. We will compare their purposes, explain how they work together, and outline the significant benefits of implementing both.

What is ISO 27001?

ISO 27001 is the leading international standard for an Information Security Management System (ISMS). Its primary purpose is to help organisations of any size or industry protect their information assets in a systematic and cost-effective way. An ISMS is a framework of policies and procedures that includes all legal, physical, and technical controls involved in an organisation’s information risk management processes.

The core of ISO 27001 is risk management. It requires organisations to identify information security risks, assess their potential impact, and implement appropriate controls to mitigate them.

Key focus areas of ISO 27001:

• Information security management: establishes a comprehensive system to manage sensitive company information, ensuring it remains secure.
• Data protection: safeguards personal and corporate data against unauthorised access, use, disclosure, alteration, or destruction. This aligns with regulations like GDPR.
• Risk mitigation: provides a structured process for identifying, analysing, and treating information security risks.
• Business continuity: ensures that an organisation can continue to operate even when faced with a security incident like a data breach or cyber-attack.

Almost every organisation today handles valuable data, making ISO 27001 relevant across all sectors.

What is ISO 42001?

ISO 42001 is the world’s first international management system standard for Artificial Intelligence (AI). Published in December 2023, it provides a framework for organisations to responsibly develop, provide, or use AI systems. Its goal is to help organisations manage the unique challenges and risks associated with AI.

Similar to other ISO management standards, ISO 42001 helps organisations build an AI Management System (AIMS). This system integrates AI governance into an organisation’s existing processes, ensuring that AI technologies are used ethically and effectively while meeting regulatory and stakeholder expectations.

Key focus areas of ISO 42001:

• Responsible AI governance: establishes policies and objectives for the development and use of AI systems, focusing on ethical principles.
• AI risk management: addresses risks specific to AI, including biased algorithms, lack of transparency, and potential societal impacts.
• Lifecycle management: provides guidance for managing AI systems throughout their entire lifecycle, from conception and data acquisition to operation and decommissioning.
• Accountability and transparency: helps organisations demonstrate how their AI systems make decisions and who is accountable for their outcomes.

Organisations developing AI products, integrating AI into their services, or using AI-powered tools are the primary beneficiaries of ISO 42001. This includes software developers, healthcare tech firms, financial services, and e-commerce companies leveraging AI for automation and decision-making.

Key differences between ISO 42001 and ISO 27001

While both are management system standards that share a similar high-level structure (Annex SL), their scope and objectives are distinct. Think of it this way: ISO 27001 protects the data, while ISO 42001 governs what you do with it when applying AI.

How ISO 42001 and ISO 27001 work together

ISO 42001 and ISO 27001 are not competitors; they’re complementary partners in modern risk management. Because AI systems are built on data, strong information security is the foundation for responsible AI. You can’t have a trustworthy AI system if the data it uses is compromised.

ISO 27001 provides the essential security baseline that ISO 42001 builds upon. For example, an organisation using customer data to train a machine learning model would use ISO 27001 to secure that data against breaches. It would then use ISO 42001 to ensure the AI model doesn’t produce biased outcomes or violate customer privacy in its application.

Why companies should consider both standards

In today’s data-driven landscape, every organisation, regardless of industry, faces the dual challenge of robust cybersecurity and responsible AI management. ISO 27001 provides the essential framework for safeguarding all company data, including the critical information that fuels AI systems. This is vital for protecting sensitive customer data, intellectual property, and operational information from breaches and misuse.

Simultaneously, as AI becomes integrated into products and services across sectors, ISO 42001 ensures that these AI systems are developed and deployed ethically and reliably. This standard addresses concerns such as preventing algorithmic bias, ensuring transparency in AI decision-making, protecting privacy in AI applications, and mitigating risks associated with AI-generated content or recommendations.

Integrating both standards into a unified management system creates a powerful framework. Security controls from ISO 27001 can be extended to cover AI-specific data and systems, while the governance structure of ISO 42001 ensures that security is considered throughout the AI lifecycle.

Four benefits of having both ISO 42001 and ISO 27001

Pursuing certification for both standards delivers compounding value that goes beyond simple compliance.

1.      Enhanced operational efficiency and compliance

An integrated management system reduces duplication of effort in policy creation, risk assessments, and internal audits. This streamlined approach saves time and resources. It also prepares your organisation for current and future regulations, which could emphasise responsible AI use.

2.      Improved risk management and data security

Combining these standards provides a holistic view of risk. You can manage threats to your data (ISO 27001) and threats from your AI applications (ISO 42001) under one cohesive strategy. This dual focus strengthens your overall security posture and resilience.

3.      Increased trust and credibility with stakeholders

Certification in both standards is a powerful signal to customers, investors, and partners. It demonstrates a commitment to not only securing data but also using powerful technologies like AI ethically and responsibly. This builds a deep level of trust that is essential for long-term success.

4.      Competitive advantage

In a crowded market, dual certification can be a significant differentiator. It shows that your organisation is proactive, forward-thinking, and dedicated to the highest standards of governance. This can help you win new business, attract top talent, and establish your brand as a leader in trustworthy technology.

Manage risk with ISO 27001 and 42001

ISO 27001 and ISO 42001 are distinct but highly complementary standards that address two of the most critical challenges in business today: information security and artificial intelligence. While ISO 27001 lays the foundation by securing your data, ISO 42001 builds on it to ensure your AI systems are managed responsibly.

By adopting both, organisations can create a robust framework for managing risk, demonstrating compliance, and building trust. This integrated approach not only enhances security and operational efficiency but also provides a clear competitive advantage in an increasingly AI-driven world.

How can Citation Certification help?

Complimentary online training for all clients: we offer complimentary online training courses for our clients that can be accessed by your entire organisation – it’s the best way to gain confidence and knowledge and help you prepare for your audit.

Partner with us to get your business to higher standards: with 30 years of experience, Citation Certification has partnered with thousands of organisations on their certification journey.

Lean on us to access our expertise: feel at ease knowing that our auditing team are supportive, friendly and personable people who are passionate about high standards. They’re locally based and dedicated to delivering high-quality customer care. Have a question or need some guidance on a standard? We’re always available to answer any questions you have. Contact us here.